Skip to navigation Skip to content Skip to footer

Women's Soccer Falls Short in Pursuit of Fourth CAC Championship

Women's Soccer Falls Short in Pursuit of Fourth CAC Championship

FREDERICKSBURG, VA – The York College women's soccer team saw their bid for a fourth Capital Athletic Conference championship come up short on Saturday in Fredericksburg, Virginia. The University of Mary Washington Eagles earned their conference-leading 14 CAC crown as they downed the Spartans 4-0 in the 2019 championship match. The title is the Eagles first since 2009, their longest drought between CAC championships. The title run for the Spartans was a Cinderella type journey as York entered the tournament as the fourth seed. York beat the fifth-seed St. Mary's Seahawks in the opening round and followed that with a win over top-seeded Salisbury before falling in the championship game. 


Match #22 – CAC Championship Match

Final Score: York 0, Mary Washington 4

Records: York 9-13, Mary Washington 11-10

Shots: York 5, Mary Washington 10

Shots on Goal: York 2, Mary Washington 5

Corner Kicks: York 1, Mary Washington 3

Saves: York 1, Mary Washington 2

Fouls: York 10, Mary Washington 8 


How It Happened:

• The Eagles seized control of the match early on as they found the back of the net a mere 3:53 into the game. Abby Zimmerman took the ball past a Spartan defender and slid a pass to Mikaela O'Fallon who hit a shot past Spartan goalie Cat McCarty for the 1-0 lead.

• The Eagles struck again a mere two and a half minutes later as O'Fallon hit a cross that found Brielle Mitchell. Mitchell finished the chance and the Eagles took a 2-0 lead less than seven minutes into the game. The goal was Mitchell's team-leading seventh of the year.

• The Spartans had a good chance on the ensuing possession as senior captain Natalie McCarthy put a shot on cage but Eagle keeper Allison Nook made the save. The Eagles finished the first half with a 5-3 edge in total shots and a 2-1 margin in shots on goal.

• The Eagles put the game away less than 15 minutes into the second half as they recorded back-to-back goals that came 36 seconds apart, turning a two-goal deficit into a four-goal bulge quickly. O'Fallon recorded her second goal of the game and fifth goal of the year with a tally off a Brooke Bauman assist at the 57:16 mark. Macey Wissell made it 4-0 with a goal off a Zimmerman assist, essentially putting the game out of reach.

• York got a shot on goal from Georgia Gillcrist in the 63rd minute but Nook notched her second save and York wouldn't have another opportunity the remainder of the game.


Spartan Leaders:

Georgia Gillcrist: 2 shots, 1 shot on goal

Natalie McCarthy: 1 shot on goal


Eagle Leaders:

Mikaela O'Fallon: 2 goals, 1 assist, 3 shots, 2 shots on goal

Macey Wissell: 1 goal, 2 shots, 1 shot on goal

Brielle Mitchell: 1 goal, 2 shots, 1 shot on goal

Abby Zimmerman: 2 assists

Brooke Bauman: 1 assist


Goalie Comparison

Cat McCarty (YCP): 90:00 minutes played, 4 goal against, 1 save (Loss, 5-7)

Allison Nook (UMW): 90:00 minutes played, 0 goals against, 2 saves (Win, 7-6)



Mary Washington leads the all-time series against the Spartans 21-11-5 as the Eagles went 2-1 against the Green and White this year with the home team winning all three matches … the match was the final one for the Spartans as a member of the Capital Athletic Conference as the Green and White heads to the MAC next fall … York is now 3-4 all-time in CAC Championship games … York is now 5-7 against Mary Washington in the CAC Tournament and 1-2 in CAC Championship games … the win for UMW is the first for the home team when matching up against the Spartans in a CAC Championship game … York finishes their stay in the CAC with an all-time tournament record of 20-17-7.


Up Next

The loss ends the Spartan season which means York must say goodbye to a memorable senior class as Natalie McCarthy, Jo Nicholson, Georgia Gillcrist, Ryan Hussey, and Ally Badman have concluded their York careers.